It’s almost that time of year again, time for the Easter bunny to hop into our homes delivering baskets full of treats for our kids. While candy is often found in Easter baskets, there are many other non-candy Easter basket stuffer options. Today we’re going to give you a list of 47 highly rated and very Easter appropriate Easter basket stuffers you can order from Amazon. Bonus, if you’re a Prime member, you’ll also get fast and free shipping.

(This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)

Easter Basket Stuffers for Toddlers

Let’s start with the little ones. The rest of the categories are going to feature toys for slightly older children; although, many are still toddler appropriate. This list is specifically for the little ones. Here are my top picks for Easter basket stuffers for toddlers:

1. The Big Easy Easter Egg Coloring Book For Ages 1-4
2. TOMY Toomies Hide & Squeak Easter Eggs
3. LeapFrog Shapes & Sharing Picnic Basket
4. Easter Egg Shakers for Kids
5. Infantino Lil’ Nibbles Textured Silicone Teether, Orange Carrot

Egg-Shaped Surprise Inside Toys

There are a wide variety of toys in this category, and they are very popular with kids. Hatchimals, Rainbowcorns and Smashers are just a few of the popular options. The appeal is that there is usually one big toy inside plus there are usually multiple additional smaller surprises inside. While these toys are great for birthdays, holidays and really any day, what makes them extra appropriate for Easter is that they are shaped like an egg. Here are some of our favorite picks for Easter baskets:

1. Smashers Mega Light Up Dino T-Rex
2. Hatchimals CollEGGtibles, Bunny Family Spring Basket
3. Rainbocorns Puppycorn Rescue
4. Dig a Dozen Dino Egg Dig Kit
5. Hatchimals CollEGGtibles, Rainbow-Cation Family Hatchy Home Playset

LEGOs

My kids love LEGOs. I often try to find an Easter-themed LEGO set to give them for the holiday, but sometimes it’s even better just to get them a LEGO set they’ve been wanting for awhile. One great thing about LEGOs is that the boxes are fairly small and can fit well in most Easter baskets. In addition, it’s an activity that will keep kids engaged for quite awhile. They might even forget about the candy. Here are some of my top LEGO set picks for Easter:

1. 1. LEGO Creator 3in1 White Rabbit 31133
   2. LEGO Easter Rabbits Display 40523
   3. LEGO Flower Bouquet 10280
   4. LEGO Disney Princess Twirling Rapunzel 43214
   5. LEGO City Wild Animal Rescue Missions 60353

Activity Books

There are many great Easter-themed activity books out there. These include books of mazes, coloring books and sticker books. No matter what kind of activities your kids like, there’s a book for that. I love activity books because they’re also great to bring with us on road trips and to restaurants. Here are some of my top activity book picks for Easter:

1. Easter Mazes Book for Kids
2. Easter Joke Book for Kids
3. Paint by Sticker Kids: Easter
4. Simple Easy Easter Coloring Book for Adults
5. The Beginner’s Bible Come Celebrate Easter Sticker and Activity Book
6. Easter Deliveries (Peter Cottontail) Coloring Book

Books

If you’re celebrating Easter for the religious holiday it is, this is a great time to give your child a children’s Bible or devotional. If you’re celebrating Easter more as a fun bunny and chick themed holiday, there are great books your kids will love in that springtime new life theme too. Here are my top picks for books for Easter basket stuffers:

1. NIV Adventure Bible, Hardcover
2. Jesus Calling: 365 Devotions for Kids
3. The Jesus Storybook Bible
4. The Berenstain Bears and the Easter Story
5. Little Blue Truck’s Springtime
6. Pete the Cat and the Easter Basket Bandit

Outdoor Fun

Since Easter is in the Spring, it falls at a time of year when we’re usually starting to enjoy being outside more than we were in the winter months. We’re also starting to think about summer fun and outdoor activities. That’s why Easter is a perfect time to include some fun items kids can use outside. Sand toys, bubble wands and outdoor games are all good ideas. Here are some of my top Easter basket stuffer picks that can be used outside:

1. JOYIN 2 Bubble Guns with 2 Bottles Bubble Refill Solution
2. Light Up Bunny Easter Bubble Wand
3. Top Race Ice Cream Sand Toys for Kids
4. Tagitary Beach Sand Toys Set
5. Stomp Rocket Original Jr. Rockets Launcher for Kids

Gardening Tools

Spring is a great time of year to start a garden. Amazon has great options for tiny indoor gardens as well as kid-size gardening tools for the great outdoors, all of which would easily fit in an Easter basket. Here are my top picks for gardening Easter basket stuffers:

1. ROCA Home Easter Gardening Tool Set
2. Melissa & Doug Sunny Patch Pretty Petals Gardening Tote Set
3. Melissa & Doug Sunny Patch Camo Chameleon Watering Can
4. Creativity for Kids Mini Garden
5. Creativity for Kids Dinosaur Self Watering Plant Pet

It’s All About the Bunny

Sometimes a classic bunny stuffed animal is what every Easter basket needs. I used to give my kids bunnies in their Easter baskets every year, but after a few years, they had too many bunnies and would prefer unicorns and dinosaurs instead. Whether you think your kids want a classic bunny or another furry friend in their Easter basket, here are my top picks:

1. Melissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Animal
2. White Rabbit, Disney’s Alice in Wonderland, Stuffed Animal
3. GUND Amazon Exclusive Easter Bunny with Basket
4. Disney Minnie Mouse Easter Large 19-inch Plush
5. Jurassic World Bumpy Baby Dinosaur Toy

More Kid Favorites

There are some things that never seem to go out of style, like Pokemon cards, and there are others that are newer and very popular with rave reviews. Here are some more top picks for Easter basket stuffers:

1. 50 Pokemon Cards
2. Play-Doh Eggs 24-Pack
3. The Original Slinky Walking Spring Toy
4. Move2Play, Easter Egg Toss, Kids Game
5. Candy Land Unicorn Edition

I hope this list helped you find a few great Easter basket stuffers for all the kids on your list. We own several of these items (like the picnic basket toddler toy, Bumpy dinosaur stuffy and Jesus Storybook Bible) and they are all favorites in our home. Happy Easter!